It's been a long road for the Marvel Cinematic Universe since the culmination of End Game, which seemingly changed the superhero movie scene. They've struggled to find their footing with self-inflicted missteps, too much content, with movies and characters not connecting anymore. Phase 4 had glimmers of hope, and Phase 5 has been losing its luster with each release, save for bright moments: GoG3 and Deadpool & Wolverine.
Captain America: Brave New World and Thunderbolts* will try to bring Phase 5 to a respectable end, but is it too late? CABNW does seem to keep comic book readers in mind, giving some insight into the exploration of Red Hulk's origin, with a significant emphasis on The Leader's role in creating the character. Thankfully, the movie remains faithful to this origin, which might be refreshing for some comic enthusiasts.
Anthony Mackie, who always seems to have chemistry with his co-stars in both action and dialogue, fully engages in the role, adding depth to his character as much as the dozen rewrites and reshoots allow. Even though the debate of "Am I worthy of the shield?" should've been resolved in 'Falcon and Winter Soldier', Mackie adds, "Should I have taken the Super Serum, now that I'm THE guy?". It adds depth to his character, but unfortunately, the film has too many other flaws to give it gravitas.
The film does have some fun elements. The back-to-classic 80/20 serious-to-comedic MCU balance that's been missing is effectively used, giving it a lighthearted tone amidst intense moments, but many jokes don't land precisely enough. As for intensity, the fight scenes, while not groundbreaking, are still enjoyable and contribute visual flair to the film’s dramatic moments.
However, the adaptation isn't flawless. The score, for instance, is a noticeable misstep. Instead of enhancing the film’s atmosphere, the music often attempts to create tension, but comes across awkwardly, clashing with the tone of certain scenes and becoming more distracting than immersive.
The script, though not entirely disastrous, has its shortcomings. Some dialogue feels awkward and forced—particularly in a scene where a conversation between characters seems unnatural and out of place. This may be due to the film's troubled production, which involved numerous rewrites and reshoots, indicating the script wasn't as polished as it could have been. Mackie’s on-screen chemistry with a specific character highlights a significant issue with the movie: it exemplifies what's lacking elsewhere in terms of script. Their relationship is compelling enough to reveal weaknesses in other parts of the film.
Lastly, the film suffers from significant plot holes that are hard to overlook. Some story moments are glossed over too conveniently, leaving substantial gaps in the narrative that might have the audience scratching their heads as the credits roll.
While the movie has strengths, it lacks a cohesive and satisfying experience. Fans might appreciate its nods to the comics and Mackie’s performance, but the inconsistency in tone, weak script, and glaring plot holes may leave many pondering what could have been and where we are going.
3/5
An articulate dissection of what sounds like a flawed but not terrible movie. It certainly leaves me wanting to watch the movie, even if for no other reason than to come back to this review and see how it resonates once viewed. Really interesting review Elle, thanks.